And you think that all I did today is work? Hah!
This morning I was roped into a conversation with some very conservative colleagues who were discussing whether John McCain is actually eligible to run for President because he was born in the Panama Canal Zone. Here's the full story in the New York Times.
At issue is the interpretation of Article II, Section 1, Paragraph 5 of the U.S. Constitution:
No person except a natural born citizen, or a citizen of the United States, at the time of the adoption of this Constitution, shall be eligible to the office of President; neither shall any person be eligible to that office who shall not have attained to the age of thirty five years, and been fourteen Years a resident within the United States.
*snip*
My feeling is that he is eligible. He was born to American parents in a territory, which at the time, was under the control and laws of the United States federal government. I prefer the looser interpretation for quite selfish reasons. Despite my very "American" birthplace, I am of Puerto Rican descent, and should a viable Puerto Rican-born Presidential candidate emerge sometime in the future, I would hate to see that person excluded because of some "strict" interpretation of the term "natural born."
However, my intent in raising this issue is not to further this idiotic debate of McCain's citizenship. Nor is it to endorse McCain's Presidential candidacy in any way shape or form. After all, what am I supposed to think of a former POW who was tortured by the North Vietnamese Army and was outspoken against torture, who then goes and votes against limiting the CIA to the 19 interrogation techniques outlined in the U.S. Army Field manual? This is not the same as Hillary Clinton changing her mind about the Iraq War. Not by a long shot.
What I want to know is why, all of a sudden, is John McCain's candidacy being vilified over his eligibility as a citizen? More importantly, who's behind it? Is he being swift-boated by his own peeps? It seems that way. Yesterday, DCup of Politits posted this missive on American Street about how the neo-cons, who once supported McCain, are now stabbing him in the back because he has disavowed their attack tactics on Democratic candidates. Et tu, Bill Cunningham? Indeed.
But there's more to it than that. Distributorcap has a great post up about the latest attacks on Obama, which alludes to a similar question of loyalty. In Obama's case, the question surrounds his Muslim-sounding middle name (Hussein) and the implication that, as President, he would be overly-sympathetic to Muslim terrorists at the expense of American security. In other words, he's disloyal. It appears that this new form of swift-boating of both the presumptive Republican and Democratic candidates is attempting to scare Americans into answering these insidious questions:
Do we trust a non-natural born or Muslim-named person to be President of the United States?
Given their pedigree, can they keep their promise to "preserve, protect and defend the Constitution of the United States?"
You and I know this is a bullshit, straw man argument. Apparently, the neo-con sect of the GOP doesn't think so. Here's a story in the Washington Post that seems to make this point. You decide.
My opinion is that the neo-cons are trying to tear down McCain because his campaign team sees them as a liability. Sure, he supports the war in Iraq and is willing to trade our Constitutional freedoms for the delusion of greater security. But could it be that McCain is repudiating their brand of "true authoritarianism", as DCup wrote? Could it be that he is seeing the light of what 8 years under Bush II has done to this country and is positioning himself -- ever so slightly -- as a different sort of Republican?
If I were on the McCain campaign team, I'd take seriously the President's 19 percent approval rating and stories like this one on the AP Wire that say the economy has slowed to a near crawl. While it's a long shot that John McCain will successfully walk the entire length of this tight rope and become President, given the current economic and political climate against the Bush Administration, I'd be distancing myself from the neo-cons, too.
Naturally, they're not very happy about this, and have exponentially ratcheted up their petulance in the form of this eligibility challenge. They'll do whatever they can to give even the staunchest McCain supporters pause, because the alternative is the loss of political power. They could be relegated back to the marginal place in the American political sphere they occupied in the 70s, 80s and 90s, and they don't like the prospect of this one bit. Can you imagine a world where Ann Coulter's 500-page rants are not on the New York Times bestseller list? They can't.
I wish all of you could have been flies on the wall while my two colleagues politely (imagine that) argued this point. I could not help but be drawn in because it was rather loud. What amazed me was how easily these two seemingly, intelligent, audit professionals could not see what was going on here.
Both are Republicans who will likely support McCain come November, should he be chosen as the Republican nominee. But to quote one of my colleagues, "I prefer a stricter interpretation of the Constitution. And if McCain is ineligible, he should not be allowed to run." If you're keeping score folks, give this round to the neo-cons because that's precisely the skewed logic they want prospective McCain voters to see.
On the one hand, it makes me laugh to see this GOP infighting happening. Shit, it's downright Democratic. However, I am waiting with bated breath to see if McCain caves and takes another swig of the neo-con Kool-Aid and gets back on message. After all, if he could change his mind on the issue of torture, there's no telling what he might do in response to this attack on his status as natural born American.
Okay, I've taken too much of your time. Get back to fucking work!!!!
One More Article / Un Altro Articolo
-
Over the years teaching at La Scuola d’Italia NY, I have learned that
children are not just students; they are careful observers of the world,
full of q...
8 months ago





My understanding is that since he was born of two American parents (his father was in the navy at that time) he qualifies. That said, I hope the in-fighting continues and gets really bloody.
ReplyDeleteI'm with you on that gmb. I love watching these fuckers beat the shit out of their own.
ReplyDeleteThe only noise about McCain's eligibility is found on the Internet -- as the NY Times article states:
ReplyDelete"But whether he qualifies as natural-born has been a topic of Internet buzz for months, with some declaring him ineligible while others assert that he meets all the basic constitutional qualifications..."
It's all nonsense. The logic test is simple and clean. First, a presidential candidate must be a citizen. But not a "naturalized" citizen.
There are only two types of citizens in the US: "natural born" and "naturalized."
You are one or the other. McCain is NOT a "naturalized" citizen. But he is a citizen. Hence, since he is a citizen, he is a "natural born" citizen.
A person born to two "natural born" US citizens while those two parents are stationed at a US military facility in another country IS a "natural born" citizen. This is not a question anywhere except in the minds of people kicking something around on the Internet.
There's NO GOP infighting over this non-issue.
On the other hand, Obama cuts it close. He's a "natural born" citizen because the US has loose citizenship laws. Even if both his parents had illegally crossed into the US from another country in time for his birth, he'd be a "natural born" citizen for the simple fact of having been born on US soil. If his parents were illegal aliens, he'd still be a "natural born" citizen.
In fact, only his mother was a "natural born" citizen. If she had given birth to Obama in Kenya, his presidential eligibility status would be questionable.
Spartacus - Thanks for the link. I think this is great analysis about the McCain dilemma vis a vis the Neocons. It's going to be a rough ride for him, I think.
ReplyDeleteBah. Everyone knows that Republicans are alien invaders from beyond the moon.
ReplyDeletePositioning himself is right. "Why of course I'm not as nuts as those other guys!"
Great post. I was extremely disappointed in his vote against limiting torture, and of course, I won't be voting for him, but any argument that he's not a "natural-born citizen" is ridiculous.
ReplyDeleteThe right wing tactics should be of no surprise to anyone. In short, if they can't kill ya, then they discredit you. You can’t even say it’s a democratic or a republican issue; it’s a money issue. They don’t want anyone in the white house who is going to f-ck w/ the money. Or, anyone who has the balls to expose them.
ReplyDeleteSo, you have to ask yourself, they have successfully vilified Hillary, and all of a sudden a story was written in the NY times about McCain's alleged infidelities. Hmmm sounds familiar. Only our former President, eventually took the bait, and got a little somesome.
So who’s left OBAMA! Good guy, maybe, but green as green can be….
PERFECT! Just what the doctor ordered. Business as usual
Lil sis J
i love the smell of GOP blood on each others hands --- the McCain argument is a poor one -- he is a natural citizen --- it is just another "we need to fill in the lack of news topics" and maybe it is a way for the neo cons to keep up their attacks
ReplyDeleteand much to slappz chagrin -- McCain's status is much more slippery than Obama's. any person born on american soil is a natural citizen, regardless of their parents, even if they are illegals. (which he states) if he doesnt like the citizenship laws maybe he can move far away.
spart -- love the new look
My husband and I disagree on the meaning of "natural born." I agree that it means he was born a U.S. citizen, which he was, but my husband believes at that time the Founding Fathers really meant born on United States soil.
ReplyDeleteEither way I doubt anyone will challenge his right to be President, especially given the conservative Supreme Court we have now.
We are a nation of immigrants, and our founding fathers were not born on US soil.
ReplyDeleteThis is such bullshit. I mean they have successfully duped us into going to war, and lied to us about why! No…they weren’t lied to, and it wasn’t a mistake; the son went to do what the daddy started. ….AND they used our tax dollars to do it, all the while using scare tactics to increase fuel prices and make RECORD PROFITS!
……………….Bottom line, WE ARE BROKE (OUR NATION THAT IS) AND THEY ARE NOT (THE BUSHES, BINLADENS, CHENEYS, ROVES, RUMSFELDS)
……………WHY?!! You ask.
…….LET ME BREAK IT DOWN……MONEY CONTROLS POLICY …….That’s it in a nutshell, and I’m F’n Mad.
lil sis
Hey homie, can you contact me via the "Contact" link at Jonestown?
ReplyDeleteI accidentally deleted your email address clearing out my cache.
I have a question I'd like to ask, and I'd prefer to keep it on the DL.
In response to Mauigirl's comment- any territory means US soil. I am sure your DH will be glad to have me waving my finger in his face!!
ReplyDeleteThis whole thing is inane.
But I am glad I finally made it to Spartacus' blog!
Hey All (and yes that means you too, slappz), my apologies for not getting back to you on some of the comments you've made. I agree with Fran and my sister Senoracosa on this -- it's a straw man argument designed to shift our attention away from the real issue. While I don't think that McCain is not the guy to run this country, discrediting him as ineligible to run is just plain stupid.
ReplyDeletesenoracosa says...We are a nation of immigrants, and our founding fathers were not born on US soil.
ReplyDeleteWhat is the importance of the birth places of our "Founding Fathers"? Only a couple of them became presidents and I'll bet those who reached the presidency were born somewhere in the 13 colonies. They were as American as people could be at that moment.
You claim:
"...all the while using scare tactics to increase fuel prices and make RECORD PROFITS!"
Oil companies are earning record profits because global demand for refined petroleum products is rising. But the biggest winners are the governments of countries like Venezuela, Kuwait, Saudi Arabia, Mexico and Nigeria.
China and India are driving the rising demand for oil. A third of the world's population lives in those two countries and those people are buying cars faster than they're reproducing.
In these days of high oil-company profits, the net profit margin of these companies is 10%. For every dollar of revenue, a dime is profit. That's an unremarkable percentage.
Microsoft has a net profit margin of almost 25%. For every dollar of its revenue, almost 25 cents is net profit.
Meanwhile, global oil consumption is 85 million barrels a day. About 25 million barrels go to the US. But soon, global consumption will hit 100 million barrels a day. However, countries other than the US will consume most of the extra 15 million barrels of daily production.
Why? In a word -- prosperity. Things are improving in India and China, and other countries.
Furthermore, oil companies don't limit oil production. But governments do. Including ours.
There are 80 billion barrels of proven reserves under US soil that are off-limits to drillers.
It's astounding. In a time when people are sreaming about jobs leaving the US for countries where labor is cheaper, our government -- with full support from Dems -- prohibits the exploitation of domestic reserves. Why? Pumping our oil puts American oilfield workers to work, and it puts that $100-a-barrel back into the US economy. Meanwhile, domestic oil production puts huge amounts of tax dollars into the US Treasury.
You said:
"Bottom line, WE ARE BROKE (OUR NATION THAT IS) AND THEY ARE NOT (THE BUSHES, BINLADENS, CHENEYS, ROVES, RUMSFELDS)……………WHY?!! You ask.…….LET ME BREAK IT DOWN……MONEY CONTROLS POLICY"
Money controls policy? Is there any policy that requires NO money? What is free?
Well said.
ReplyDelete