There's a story in my local paper Newsday titled, "The Match", which profiles a local family's efforts to save their daughter from a rare blood disorder called Diamond Blackfan Anemia. The solution, as they saw it, was to have a child that is an exact genetic match to their daughter and extract the younger child's bone marrow and transplant it into her in the hopes that it would jump start her body into producing red blood cells.
There is a question of medical ethics here that is easily trumped by justifiable efforts of two very desperate parents wanting to save the life of a child. What parent wouldn't do that? However, that's an incomplete, if not misleading question, once you consider the relative wealth of the family in question. The Trebings are from Smithtown, NY, an affluent suburb on the North Shore of Suffolk County. One look at pictures of them in their beautiful home, and one can easily assume that these people are not for want of money. They probably have very good health care coverage, too. And, of course, they're white.
Before anyone goes on to blast me for sour grapes over their wealth and the attendant privilege that comes with it, understand that I am not at odds with or envious of what the Trebings have. I grew up poor and, yet, I can honestly say that my parents provided quite well for me despite our economic standing. And I'm not very different than the Trebings in what I would do to save a member of my family. I would do anything within my means to save my wife and children from disease.
The dog? Feh....(Only kidding Chester. You're family, too.)
And like the Trebings, I, too, am gainfully employed and live in a nice house in Pete King's "red" district. E. and I could not be considered poor by any standard. We both work and have health coverage, which she foregos for a cash payout every June because my employer-provided coverage takes care our whole family, excluding Chester (those bastards!!!). Although our coverage is not as good as the Trebings.
But there are others in our neighborhood who don't have it as well as we do; many of whom E. comes into contact with at the school in which she works. On an almost daily basis, she brings home her own heart-wrenching stories of parents who beg to get their children placed into either the free and reduced lunch program; or who get upset with her because the school doesn't provide after-school daycare. Clearly, these people -- these good people -- are not making what we make on annual basis, let alone the amount the Trebings rake in. And, unlike the Trebings and my family, these people, by and large, are people of non-white ethnicities, who have the same basic needs and desires, if not the means. They can't afford experimental surgery to save their child, let alone afford to send them to school with something healthy to eat. What's more is that they are legion.
So, why is it that this story garners more attention than that of the poor folks in my wife's school? After all, they're both heart-wrenching stories. The key difference is that one story is about a wealthy white family that found happiness and success in the end. The other is a collection of desperate tales of woe that end sadly for those poor kids in need of a free meal. If you were one of Newsdays many well-off, white readers, which story are you prefer to read?
You can answer that question in the comments section if you like, but when I saw the story on Monday when I got home from work, I peeled off the 16-page pullout to get to the real news. The one that's got my knickers in a twist now is of the Gestapo tactics being used by U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) agents to round up illegal immigrants. (Read about it here.) Yes, we are now living in a facist state.
But I'll give credit where it's due. We ought to see stories about medical ethics because advances in medical technology have put us at a very dangerous precipice. We can now harvest human organs. Further, reporter Beth Whitehouse and her editors did a wonderful job of framing the issue in this light, and giving it a human face. Browse through the sections contained in the initial Newsday story link above and you'll discover all there is to know about Diamond Blackfan Anemia; the controversial treatment options available; the fact that they conceived a child invitro that is a perfect genetic match to their very sick daughter; and (surprise, surprise) that the treatment worked. The little girl is cured. I want to and should feel good about this, but I don't.
That's because with all due respect to the editors of Newsday, Beth Whitehouse, and the Trebings, this is not news. In fact, this is the kind of story that ought to be published in People magazine (which I don't read) along side other feel-good stories, like Lindsay's day with dad. It's a sell job and a shameless one at that. Yesterday's chapter even included a sidebar about the latest Jody Picoult's book My Sister's Keeper -- yet another tear-jerker from the new queen of chick-lit written in the usual large type, short sentence style, all enclosed in sexy, pastel-colored cover art. MSK is a story of a woman who was conceived for the sole purpose of keeping her older sister alive, and sued her parents to keep her body from being harvested further. Talk about a cross-marketing opportunity!
When you get right down to it stories, like these, and the preference that Americans have speak alot to how fucked up our priorities have become. Can you imagine a story like this running in the 1930s at the height of the depression? How would an unemployed, bread-liner respond to the Trebing crisis? Better still, casting this question onto a more recent tragedy, how would the people of New Orleans' devastated 9th Ward respond? What would be their take on this crisis?
I know what they would say -- and it's alot stronger than the tame, feh. In fact, I suspect it would be well beyond the incredulous, Are you fucking kidding me?
Really. Again, I don't begrudge the Trebings anything, and I am quite glad to hear that the treatment worked.
I also don't begrudge Newsday the right to publish stories such as these. They are in the business of selling newspapers, and in order to be successful in this business, they must bow to the tastes of the market they serve; even if the story is of the self-serving, feel-good People magazine variety.
No. My screed is directed at the people who can't see beyond the tips of their noses and recognize the real issues of the day; those folks who willfully ignore the problems our nation faces, choosing instead to revel in some deluded feel-good fantasy world where the only stories worth reading are ones like the Trebings' crisis where everything turns out okay. Call it escapist, unrealistic or what you will, but this is bullshit.
Is this a question of ethics? You betch ya. It's a question of whether we, as a nation, have any left.
One More Article / Un Altro Articolo
-
Over the years teaching at La Scuola d’Italia NY, I have learned that
children are not just students; they are careful observers of the world,
full of q...
8 months ago





This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteDCup -
ReplyDeleteYou make some great points here, and I agree, a market driven press is definitely better than one which is state run. These days, however, I wonder if the MSM is more the latter than the former.
But let's operate under the premise that the news industry is market driven. What does our "market" preference for soft and titillating news "market" say about us as a society? Do we really care about what's going on in our world? I've always felt that the function of a free and independent press was to act as a check against the information the government passes on, and when your lead story on the evening news is the lastest in the Spears-Federline custody battle, I'm left with the sinking sense that we are fucked because we've abdicated our right to demand hard news.
My current news sources consist of NPR and the internet. Does that make me a lame duck liberal? Am I too far out of the infostream?
ReplyDeleteBut damn, I think if I listened to any of that crap on TV or read the papers I'd be more depressed and angry than I already am, and coming from a family of manic depressives, this head-in-the-sand mentality might been seen as a precautionary measure. Hell, I could get a prescription for ignorance, but I think my Unitarian and Quaker friends might diss me for that.
Kimono -
ReplyDeleteI don't think that makes you a lame duck lib at all. In fact, your news source choices speak volumes to your ability to discern bullshit news from stuff you really need to know.
In fact, my gripe isn't necessarily with the fluff because sometimes I dig watching the train wreck. I do. But when it's passed off as pertinent news or aimed at my emotion and not at my intellect, I get rather insulted. There's a bit of self-loathing in my post here because I am as guilty as anyone for not demanding more of my news sources. I read Newsday because, by and large, it is still THE best source for information, political and otherwise, in my neck of the woods -- Long Island. I guess I was just venting my frustration at them because this story just doesn't deserve the attention they're giving it and because they are "selling out" to the softies.
I think a lazy press and media is to blame for some of this. Why chase down the worthy stories when the viewer or reader will be content to know what someone like Spears is doing. It takes much more effort to dig into a story than to simply repeat nothing much more than gossip.
ReplyDeleteThe story about the family and their daughter is one I would have skipped over. Just not interesting to me. I'm glad it worked out for them, but as informative news goes, it doesn't make the grade.
Well POP...you may have a point there. Perhaps they are looking to pick the low hanging fruit and nit really chasing difficult stories. However, as a regular Newsday reader, they're not that bad. This is also the paper that did a series on the dead of the Iraq war -- and not just the white soldiers, either. They also did a series on the illegal immigration situation and covered it quite well.
ReplyDeleteBut any daily is only as good as your last story, right? What I'm saying is that even supposedly good newspapers have to bow to "market" forces and that market is the collective us.
Even in Spain on CNN international, I was kept abreast of Brittney's situation.
ReplyDeleteThis world is f-ed.
But glad to be back at your blog!
how much money does Bushco funnel to CNN and MSNBC to keep this crap in the forefront
ReplyDeleteThere is a way out other than expatriation, but I see it every day BECAUSE of my expatriation. My adopted country would be fantasyland for left and right as well. There is complete single-payer National Health, no restrictions on contraception nor abortion, gay marriage, etc. Their are hard caps on what private insurers may charge. The budget is in surplus. The police are demilitarized. And people GET ALONG. Oh, you think the right might like the tax code here? Max tax on ordinary income is 10% before any deductions or adjustments. Max cap gains is 2%. Property rights are sacrosanct. One may maintain public and private contracts as to the same asset for tax and financial accounting purposes. Legally. Bank privacy is sacrosanct. Internet and phone records are sacrosanct. There are no cameras filming the populace's every move. College and post-graduate education are high-subsidized. The public schools in the big cities are pretty good but private schools don't cost $30K/annum. $5K would be A LOT.
ReplyDeleteHow do they do it? Well, obviously, it doesn't require a great deal of sacrifice on the poor and middle class, but in order to secure those low taxes and property rights, the defense budget had to be cut down to the barest minimum necessary to protect infrasctructure and vital services. And the HMO/Insurance/Pharma complex had to be brought to hell. And the government had to get out of the way of the bank's business beyond collecting the wholly reasonable corporate taxes.
That is how it's done. The question facing America right now is: does the love of all things military and all law enforcement and punishment and such intrustive instruments of government as THE DEPARTMENT OF HOMELAND SECURITY really merit the destruction of the economy, when all sides of the political spectrum can easily be served by remembering the importance of a single word: PRIVACY.
I do not believe you are advanced enough yet to make the leap. All the leap requires is changes to "defense" contracting and appropriations, the medical racket, the system of tax collection, and the system of banking! Not such a tall order to fill in maybe 100 years.
Until then, dear Spartacus and E., buckle tight. Maybe fascism will be good.