After writing my last post and possibly pissing off a few people in the process, I felt it necessary to explain the genesis of my atheism. Below is a post from an previous blog I used to write. Not that anyone cares, but hopefully, it provides some context to how I came discard 35 years of Roman Catholic indoctrination. I've seen moved beyond the agnosticism expressed below and I'm very comfortable with the idea that we are born, live, die and turn to dust. Anything after that is speculation without proof. But I digress.
First posted 6 October 2004:
I was raised as a Roman Catholic and to this day continue to attend regular mass with my wife and kids, out of respect for my wife's wishes to raise our children in this manner. I have no objection to this religious "training", but understand that I am no longer of that "faith".
My skepticism began when I learned that a large number of priests were found to have molested children in their care. The Church, in trying to avoid the scandal, tried to cover it up by paying off the injured parties and reassigning the "accused" clergy where they sometimes were left to commit the same crime again. Yet, in nearly every mass I've been to in the last 10+ years, I've heard homily after homily spout on about the evils of abortion, secular humanism, technology, you name it. It stinks of hypocrisy that this "so-called" moral authority can damn acts contrary to their doctrine on one hand, yet offer safe haven for criminals in their midst and call it an act of salvation. I suppose it's not just a human trait to protect your own but a "divine" one as well. But my skepticism runs deeper than that.
Not long after the RC Church scandal broke wide open here in the US, I read a book titled "Guns, Germs and Steel" by Jared Diamond which offered a different take on world history and how we as the highest order of mammals evolved to the present day. This book does not simply espouse unsupported theories, but attempts to explain our development as humans relative to the development world at large. He offered cogent explanations on the the development of plants as food, animal use in farming, languages, trade routes, the rise of political entities and centers of power. This all begs the question: Was the Earth really created by ONE God in seven days as the Judeo-Christian scriptures state? Or is Mr. Diamond right in stating that the earth evolved over tens of thousands of years and that the relative evolution of different cultures rests largely on the ecological, biological, and geological fortunes placed before them?
Finally, what cemented my skepticism was a book titled "Galileo's Mistake" by Wade Rowland. Again, another learned piece which revisits Galileo's trial in 1633 and explodes certain myths about what really happened. But make no mistake, this book is also a defense of the Church and laments the loss of spiritualism (Christian spiritualism, that is) in modern society. While I agree with Mr. Rowland that Galileo made a political mistake in challenging the Church's beliefs (afterall, at the time, heresy was a crime that carried life-threatening consequences), where I disagree with Mr. Rowland is with his notion that we've lost something spiritual by embracing the pursuit of knowledge through science. What I find particularly troubling is that he spent so much time refuting human-kind's evolution towards logical thinking while quoting the same people who developed the model. Socrates, Plato, Aristotle, Ptolemy, Aquinas, Descartes, Kant, all great philosophers and thinkers on whose thoughts rest the so-called Great Western Tradition relied heavily on logic to develop their views regardless of whether the topic was scientific or spiritual in nature. So I ask, was it wrong for Galileo to question the RC Church's notions of heaven and earth, given the evidence revealed to him with the telescopes he developed by accident? Was it not the logical learning embedded in the Western Tradition that made his discoveries and inventions possible? Or was it God-given and, therefore, lacking the all-knowing divine truth purported to belong solely to God? In practical terms, even if you assume that God is all-powerful and divine, why couldn't the Church reconcile it's views with Galileo's evidence instead of Galileo recanting his Copernican beliefs before the Inquisition? Could it have been God's intention to reveal this new information to Galileo, therefore making the RC Church's position wrong?
I don't portend to know the answers. I don't know who's right and who's wrong. Science or Faith? Christianity or Islam? God or no God? But I've pondered this for a long time and have come to the conclusion that my "faith" in anything must be supported by proof in the same way that all living beings are supported with energy. I simply cannot accept the notion that we simply live, die, and turn to dust as science would have it. Something sparked the energy that now gives us this consciousness we call life and I believe that this energy is inextinguishable. Likewise, I cannot blindly accept the notion that my "soul", which I believe this energy to be, is not really mine; that it is given to me by a "God" and can be taken away by a "God" lest I come to terms with this so-called authority. I am simply unable to suspend my notion of disbelief in this manner.
Let's face it, our capacity to reason as humans is limited by what we see, hear, feel and think. While it's true that people of science have revealed a great many discoveries to human-kind, many people of Godly faith have given us "revelations", made without prior knowledge or observation, that we still hold to be true. So on the question of who's universal view is right and wrong, I don't know. But I do know that I have allowed my mind to accept all forms of knowledge and reasoning, and made it my mission to reconcile that information with what I've known to be true in order to make a judgment for myself on whether to have faith in it or not. If I have taken the wrong track, if all I ever need is to have faith in God despite what I see, hear, feel and think, then I'll accept whatever consequence that follows when I die. Until then, I can only see, hear, feel and think my way through this earthly existence....
One More Article / Un Altro Articolo
-
Over the years teaching at La Scuola d’Italia NY, I have learned that
children are not just students; they are careful observers of the world,
full of q...
8 months ago





How very interesting!
ReplyDeleteI also find it curious that, while I certainly was/am familiar with the book Guns, Germs and Steel, I did not read it myself ...
before I gave it to my father to read this last holiday season.
I'll have to ask him what he thought of it, being has he hasn't mentioned it over the ensuing months.
- Cliff
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteI am having a hard time composing my thoughts so I will be back later. You know I could care less if you believe or not.
ReplyDeleteI would rather be with someone who has examined their conscience and being an atheist than a blind believer.
Cliff - Get that book back from your Dad. If you can't let me know and I'll send you a copy. Your mind will be that much more lucid from reading it.
ReplyDeleteDCup - I would like to count you as one of the lucky ones for not having been so deeply immersed in the "faith", but I'm not sure I can without being disingenuous. You see, this sense of community and concern for the human condition that I've developed in 43+ years of living, I learned during my years of being immersed in Roman Catholicism. So, in some sense, I owe a debt of gratitude to the RC Church. However, what I've learned after the fact is that one does not need to be faithful in order to be good and decent, which is one of the reasons why becoming an atheist was such a difficult choice for me. The sad fact is that I have alienated many friends and family with my choice -- some irreparably -- but I was compelled, nonetheless, to make this choice.
Fran - I posted this with a notion of reaching other Catholics who are/were similarly situated. I know that I can be rude sometimes with my atheism and for this I apologize. I respect deeply your choice to remain faithful, and I do appreciate the perspective you bring to the blogsphere. However, please hold your comments until you've seen Part 2 of this story, which I wil post a little later today. Thanks.
No problem- I have not found my words anyway.
ReplyDeleteI find you startlingly honest and frankly I prefer that over false piety.
Waiting for your post.
Spartacus: It took the CHILD MOLESTATION scandal to make you question?
ReplyDeleteThis is troubling indeed. Didn't they teach you in school all about the Reconquest, Inquisition, Crusades, simony, and sale of false reliquary? Or Pope Pius's complicity in Hitler's casue?
But even though I'm a Jewish atheist, I'm with FranIam on this one. We're discussing the political corruption of organzied religion, not "belief." I personally don't have a problem with believers just as I have no problem with the teachings of Jesus.
Kelso -
ReplyDeleteYou make an great point and I concede that there is some measure of hypocrisy (is that the right word here?) in what triggered the start.
In thinking about it, now, I've always known about these arguments, listened to them, and held the position that all points were how the church was then. I was a really good Catholic then, and all that mattered in matters religious was the dogma and policy that was preached.
So, yes, I learned it in school, but never really understood the significance of it until the RC Church, with utter hubris, decided to hide the whole scandal of sex offenders in their midst. I felt betrayed and angry by a church that would not listen. That's when the free pass ended I'd always given them ended. That's the point at which my respect and reverence ended.
With that end came the doubt and self-reflection and a decision -- a very scary one, mind you -- to "give of the ghost" of God and Christianity. I know this sounds so overnight-ish, but the time frame we're talking about here is much longer than the one week's difference the Part 1 and Part 2.
As for the teachings of Jesus, I think they're quite universal, don't you? Do you honestly believe that he was the first to utter or grunt that we are better served as a species by living in peace than by annihilating each other? It's okay if you do, but the way I feel now, the words purportedly to be his could have belonged to any good decent human being.